The only fair way to compare channels is to look at what each one costs you per instruction, not per click or per enquiry, and to include your own time.
Cost per instruction
For each channel over a set period, add up everything you spent, including agency fees, software, content and the value of your team's time spent managing it. Then divide by the number of instructions that channel produced. Do this separately for each practice area if you can. Two channels with very different costs per enquiry can end up much closer once conversion is taken into account.
Value per instruction
Some channels bring higher value work than others. A channel that brings fewer but larger matters can be better than one that brings many small ones. Track the fee value of instructions, not just the count.
Time to results
SEO may cost less per instruction in the long run but take months to start working. Paid search and leads can work within days but stop when you stop paying. Think about when you need the work, not only how much it costs.
Use your own numbers
General figures from other firms or other industries are rarely useful, because so much depends on your practice areas, fees, location and intake. Leaflegal does not publish conversion rates for this reason. Track your own results consistently and compare channels within your firm.
Combining channels
Most firms do best with a mix. A common pattern is to build SEO and reputation steadily as a long term base, use referrals where they come naturally, and use bought leads or paid search to add predictable volume, enter new areas or fill capacity when needed. Each channel has a different job. Buying leads does not replace your own marketing. It adds volume alongside it.
Review regularly
Markets change, costs rise and fall, and your firm's priorities shift. Review your channel mix every few months using your own numbers. Move budget towards the channels producing instructions at a cost and value that suit you, and away from those that are not. With leads, you can adjust volume, matter types and locations as you learn what works.