It helps to see the informal route side by side with the statutory one. These are general differences. Your solicitor will explain how they apply to your lease.
Certainty
Under the statutory route, a qualifying leaseholder has a legal right to a new lease on terms set by law, and the freeholder cannot refuse. Under the informal route, the freeholder can say no, change its offer or withdraw at any point before the deal is signed.
Length of the new lease
A statutory extension under the long standing rules adds 90 years to the remaining term, and the 2024 Act provides for 990 years once the relevant changes are in force. An informal extension can be any length the two sides agree. Some offers extend the lease to a round figure such as 99 or 125 years from today, which may add fewer years than a statutory claim would.
Ground rent
A statutory extension reduces the ground rent to a peppercorn. An informal offer might keep a ground rent, increase it or include a review clause. Separate rules introduced in 2022 limit ground rent on many new residential leases, and they can affect the extra years added by a voluntary extension. Your solicitor will check how they apply to an offer.
Other lease terms
The statutory route only allows limited changes to the existing lease terms. An informal deal can change anything that both sides agree to change, which can be helpful or unhelpful depending on what is proposed.
Disputes
Under the statutory route, an independent tribunal can decide the premium if you cannot agree. There is no tribunal for an informal deal. If you cannot reach agreement, the negotiation simply ends, although you may still be able to use the statutory right.
Passing it to a buyer
A statutory notice can usually be passed to a buyer if you sell part way through. An informal offer is personal to the negotiation, and a buyer may not be able to rely on it.
Costs
Under the long standing statutory rules, the leaseholder pays certain reasonable costs of the freeholder, and the 2024 Act is moving towards each side paying its own. In an informal deal there are no set rules, so who pays what is simply part of the bargain. It is worth asking for any costs contribution to be agreed as a fixed sum at the outset.